Rogers & Hollands Diamonds Review

Navigate the intricate world of Rogers & Hollands with us because we unravel the truth behind their century-long legacy, diamond quality, and where they truly shine in the jewelry market.

At BrighterGuide, we don't just offer information; we provide a curated experience steeped in authenticity and expertise. Led by Ishan B, a revered authority in the world of diamonds and jewelry, our platform sparkles with years of intricate knowledge and a profound appreciation for the beauty and craftsmanship of gemstones and precious metals. We've journeyed through the glittering maze of the industry, decoded the secrets of quality and value, and encapsulated our wisdom into a comprehensive, easy-to-understand guide. Our pledge is to illuminate your path with trustworthy, current, and actionable insights, ensuring that every choice you make shines brightly. With BrighterGuide, you're not just getting a tutorial; you're acquiring a dedicated confidant for your shimmering voyage.

Rogers & Hollands is a renowned name in the world of jewelry, known for its exquisite collection of engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. With a legacy spanning over a century, this jewelry retailer has earned a reputation for quality craftsmanship and exceptional customer service. In this Rogers & Hollands review, we’ll delve into the offerings and experiences that make this brand a trusted choice for special occasions.

Sit tight because we’re about to delve into the nuanced world of Rogers & Hollands Diamonds—a family-operated business with legacy and sparkle. With the help of BrighterGuide, you will dissect everything from the quality of their glinting diamonds to the sometimes perplexing price tags.

Key Takeaways

  • Rogers & Hollands, a family-operated jewelry business with a century-long history, offers an extensive range of jewelry options, including engagement rings and more.
  • While some diamonds are well-cut and ideal, others may have clarity issues. Pricing can be perplexing, but they offer a range of engagement ring styles and premium packaging with diamond certificates.
  • In-store, the staff at Rogers & Hollands excel in guiding customers through the selection of diamonds. However, the online shopping experience may leave some wanting more.
Rogers Holland Diamonds ring on a vibrant red background, radiating elegance and sophistication.

Related article: Shane Co Diamond Rings Review

Rich History Revisited

Say hello to Rogers & Hollands, a jewel of a company that’s been family-run since 1910. Their reach? 81 stores across ten states. Here, you’ll encounter an expansive range of jewelry options—rings, necklaces, earrings, and more. All are offered with a side dish of customer service that’s often top-notch.

Being a family-run enterprise for over a century gives Rogers & Hollands an almost romantic backstory. Their gravitas in the diamond industry is hard to ignore. It’s not just about selling glittering stones; it’s about imparting a sense of education and discernment to the customer.

As independent jewelers, they curate an impressive selection, thanks to their freedom from corporate chains. Notably, they invest in educating customers through an extensive diamond education page. You don’t just leave with a purchase; you leave a little wiser.

Assessing Diamond Quality at Rogers & Hollands

Spoiler alert: The diamonds here can be a bit of a mixed bag. In terms of the four C’s—Carat, Cut, Color, Clarity—the quality varies significantly.

The Importance of Cut

The cut is the grandmaster of diamond quality, determining the stone’s brilliance. Some of Rogers & Hollands’ diamonds are cut to near-perfection, bouncing light around like a disco ball. Ideal cut diamonds are the secret sauce of Rogers & Hollands Jewelers. This is where brilliance is born. If you’re going through the diamond-buying process and spot an ideal cut, seize it!

Carat Diamond and Level of Service

When you’re splurging on a carat diamond, the level of service you receive should be second to none. Rogers & Hollands Jewelers often have knowledgeable associates who guide you through the complex landscape of diamond quality scores and clarity grades.

For those with wedding bells on the mind, diamond engagement rings here are far from mall jewelry. The store often garners 5-star reviews, but let’s not ignore that pesky purchase price. Engagement ring styles range from pre-set rings to custom masterpieces, and yes, the purchase price is a full-on rollercoaster. But with premium packaging and diamond certificates, they’re ticking a lot of gold stars off the list.

The Clarity Conundrum

Clarity levels also have some inconsistency. You might find diamonds clear as the Caribbean Sea, while others sport inclusions that are, well, a bit too inclusive for comfort. The diamond clarity scale is your friend here, so use it wisely.

Inventory Insights: Product Offerings

Ah, the product range—where Rogers & Hollands truly flaunts its feathers. Whether you’re after engagement bling or a necklace that screams, “I’ve arrived,” there’s a good chance you’ll find it here.

Diamond Rings

Engagement rings here aren’t just rings; they’re lifetime commitments crafted into circular form. The store’s associates function as your romantic consultants, guiding you to a ring that won’t just fit your finger but also your budget. And yes, each diamond ring comes with a certificate. No funny business here.

Rogers Holland Diamonds Review ring in a box

Diamond Earrings

Rogers & Hollands offers earrings that range from ‘Wow, look at her!’ to ‘Those are cute, I guess.’ The diamond quality grades come into play, determined by—you guessed it—the 4Cs. Want something one-of-a-kind? Opt for loose diamonds to get them custom-set. It’s like building your dream home, but shinier.

Diamond Necklace

The necklaces here aim to please all necks—long, short, delicate, or bold. Diamond prices are competitive without making your wallet weep. Ethical sourcing? Check. Independent diamond testing? Double-check.


Here’s where things get, um, less sparkly. The price tags at Rogers & Hollands can sometimes leave you scratching your head, wondering if the shimmer is worth the dollars you’re parting with. But if you have a budget for your perfect engagement ring, Rogers & Hollands will find a way for you to meet those requirements.

Engraving Your Custom Designs

Engraving is where Rogers & Hollands lets you move from consumer to creator. Whether it’s etching your initials, embedding a meaningful date, or some obscure line that only you understand, custom engraving adds that final dollop of uniqueness to your shiny new purchase.

Customer Service Review

Rogers & Hollands offers a satisfactory level of customer service. The staff often brings their A-game, providing insights into diamonds and the 4 Cs. But let’s be real; there’s room for improvement. Online shoppers, for example, might find their digital experience a bit lacking.

While Rogers & Hollands, a prominent name in the United States, has garnered a reputation for quality diamond offerings, the customer experience leaves some room for refinement. One of their secret superpowers lies in the in-store expertise of their staff, especially when it comes to guiding buyers on the selection of diamonds. But the online terrain? That’s a different story.

BBB Business Profiles suggest a mix of customer reviews, both commending and critiquing Rogers & Hollands® and Rogers Jewelers. Diving into these BBB Business Profiles, it’s clear that the nature of complaints vary, with some pointing towards diamond quality, while others highlight discrepancies in the center diamond’s specifications. However, one can’t overlook the positive experience shared by many who appreciated the ambiance in mall stores like Woodfield Mall and Chicago Ridge Mall.

Final Verdict: Is Rogers & Hollands Your Gem?

Rogers & Hollands brings a mixed bag to the jewelry table. The diamond quality can range from ‘I do’ to ‘I don’t.’ The customer service experience has its highs and lows. Alternatives like James Allen might offer better value for a comparable or even smaller investment.

So, should you buy from Rogers & Hollands? If you’re willing to dig a little, educate yourself, and know precisely what you’re looking for, then absolutely. But if you’re seeking consistent quality without much effort, it might be best to check other jewelry boxes.


BrighterGuide is dedicated to providing accurate and relevant information as you explore the wonderful world of diamonds and jewelry. To this end, our writers refer to primary information sources in building each article that appears on this website. These include, but are not limited to, published news articles, government portals, research papers, and more.

  1. Rogers & Hollands. (n.d.). Online jewelry store – Rogers and Hollands® | Ashcroft and Oak®.
  2. American Gem Trade Association. (2019, December 10). Gemstones: The American Gem Trade Association. AGTA.
  3. International Gem Society LLC. (2022e, November 14). Clarity grading for Colored Gemstones – International Gem Society. International Gem Society.

Leave a Comment