Engagement Ring Alternatives: A Comprehensive Buying Guide

Discover stunning alternatives to traditional diamond engagement rings - from lab-grown diamonds to colorful gemstones and heirlooms.

At BrighterGuide, we don't just offer information; we provide a curated experience steeped in authenticity and expertise. Led by Ishan B, a revered authority in the world of diamonds and jewelry, our platform sparkles with years of intricate knowledge and a profound appreciation for the beauty and craftsmanship of gemstones and precious metals. We've journeyed through the glittering maze of the industry, decoded the secrets of quality and value, and encapsulated our wisdom into a comprehensive, easy-to-understand guide. Our pledge is to illuminate your path with trustworthy, current, and actionable insights, ensuring that every choice you make shines brightly. With BrighterGuide, you're not just getting a tutorial; you're acquiring a dedicated confidant for your shimmering voyage.

Diamond Engagement Ring Alternatives: The moment when you drop to one knee, present a small box, and ask the love of your life to marry you. But what if that small box didn’t contain a diamond ring?

What if it held something equally meaningful but far less conventional? Welcome to the world of engagement ring alternatives—a realm where love is still sealed with a token, but that token doesn’t have to cost three months’ salary or come from a mine.

In this article, BrighterGuide will explore unique and heartfelt ways to say, “Will you marry me?” without a diamond ring. So, if you’re looking to break the mold while still capturing the essence of this life-changing moment, read on.

Key Takeaways

  • Discover diverse alternatives to traditional diamond engagement rings, from lab-grown diamonds to colorful gemstones, enabling you to find a unique symbol of love.
  • Non-diamond engagement rings, inspired by Blue Nile, provide affordability, customization, and a distinctive look. However, consider the maintenance and durability of each gemstone choice.
  • When choosing an alternative engagement ring that reflects your style and love story, consider factors such as your lifestyle, gemstone preferences, and budget to make the right selection.

Your Diamond Engagement Ring: Alternatives

Let’s examine various alternatives to engagement rings set with diamonds.

For those seeking a less expensive alternative that has the beauty and toughness of a natural diamond, lab-grown diamonds are a popular choice. These marvels of modern science offer a similar sparkle and Mohs Hardness Scale to their natural counterparts but at a fraction of the cost. It’s a savvy move for the budget-conscious shopper. If you’re looking for tips on buying an engagement ring, it’s worth considering lab-created stones.

With its remarkable shine and purity, natural moissanite is still another excellent option. This gemstone is nearly as hard as a diamond and flashes with a fiery brilliance that can even exceed that of diamonds. Moissanite is a stellar choice for those who want a ring that stands out in a crowd.

Rubies, morganites, and aquamarine are additional exquisite choices that can give your engagement ring a splash of color and individuality.

Lab Grown Diamonds

For your diamond engagement ring, lab-grown diamonds provide a morally and environmentally sound substitute. While they are generated in a controlled laboratory setting as opposed to being extracted from the earth, these lab-created diamonds are chemically and physically identical to genuine diamonds. This implies that they don’t contribute to environmental harm or violations of human rights related to the diamond mining industry, and they have a lower carbon footprint.

Lab-grown diamonds are a great substitute for real diamonds for people who are concerned about how their jewelry choices affect the environment and society. They are a popular choice for alternative engagement rings since they have the same brilliance, lab-created diamond clarity, and durability as real diamonds.

By selecting a lab-grown diamond, you can have a stunning and heartfelt token of your love and change the world at the same time.

Natural Moissanite

When considering a stone that matches the allure of a diamond, natural moissanite is a standout choice, often sparking the debate of diamond vs moissanite. This gemstone not only mirrors the aesthetic appeal of its counterpart but also offers distinct advantages when it comes to selecting the centerpiece for an engagement ring.

The brilliance and fire of natural moissanite are comparable to that of diamonds. It’s a sturdy substitute stone with a comparable degree of elegance and shine that’s reasonably priced.

For an engagement ring, natural moissanite is a fantastic option for the following three reasons:

Outstanding Beauty: Natural moissanite stones have a distinct, alluring shine that is sure to draw attention from everyone. They are an incredibly beautiful option for an engagement ring since they have a brilliance that is unrivaled by other diamond substitutes.

Affordability: Compared to diamonds, natural moissanite is far less expensive, so you can get a larger stone or allocate funds to other components of your wedding. It provides a cost-effective solution for people who desire the appearance and texture of a diamond without going over budget.

Ethical and Sustainable: When choosing an engagement ring, natural moissanite is an ethical and sustainable option. You can wear your ring with pride, knowing that it was made with little harm to the environment because it was made in a laboratory using eco-friendly techniques.

As a stunning and reasonably priced substitute for diamonds in your engagement ring, think about using genuine moissanite. For individuals looking for a special and significant love symbol, it’s a great option because of its extraordinary beauty, reasonable price, and ethical attributes. Moreover, understanding the nuances of diamond sizes can be crucial in making an informed decision. For a comprehensive understanding, consider exploring a diamond size carat chart, which can provide valuable insights into how different sizes compare without compromising on your ethical standards.


As a sophisticated and modern substitute for a diamond engagement ring, aquamarine might be chosen. When searching for an inexpensive and distinctive colored gemstone, aquamarine is a stunning option. With its pale blue color, aquamarine gives any engagement ring a hint of refinement and charm. It belongs to the beryl family and is a sturdy choice for daily use, with a Mohs hardness grade of 7.5-8.

Additionally, aquamarine can be inherited as a family heritage and used as your “something blue.” For those born in March, aquamarine holds extra significance as it is their birthstone. To delve deeper into this aspect, consider exploring the allure of March aquamarine birthstones.

Aquamarine is a gorgeous substitute for a diamond engagement ring, even if it needs special storage and is sporadically polished. For a broader perspective on this enchanting gemstone, you might want to explore the various facets of aquamarine jewelry.

Affordable alternativeSeparate storage required
Beautiful light blue hueOccasional polishing necessary
Durable for everyday wear
Can be a family heirloom

As an alternative to classic diamond engagement rings, aquamarine lets you show off your unique personality and sense of flair.


Fortunately, a gorgeous and reasonably priced substitute for a diamond engagement ring is morganite. Morganite is similar to pink diamonds due to its stunning pink color, although it is less expensive.

Morganite engagement rings are a popular alternative for your proposal for three reasons:

  • Multipurpose Style: Rose gold engagement rings and morganite combine to create a stunning, romantic, and feminine style. You may design a one-of-a-kind, customized ring with its gentle and elegant tint that goes well with many different metals and gemstones.
  • Inexpensive Elegance: Morganite is a less expensive alternative to diamonds without sacrificing design or elegance. Morganite is a great option for people looking for a gorgeous ring at a reasonable price because you can acquire a larger stone for a fraction of the price of a diamond.
  • Gemstone Appeal: Love, compassion, and healing are represented by the gemstone morganite. More people are becoming aware of its growing appeal as they recognize the distinctive charm and distinctiveness that gemstone engagement rings provide. Morganite is a unique material that may create a striking ring that differs from the conventional diamond selections.


Consider a gorgeous ruby engagement ring as a daring and passionate substitute for a diamond one. Ruby is a well-known gemstone because of its brilliant red hue and remarkable beauty. It is an important option for an engagement ring since it is a representation of bravery, passion, and love.

Ruby is a hard gemstone that may be worn every day because it has a Mohs hardness value of 9. Any item of jewelry is enhanced by its deep red color, which exudes refinement and elegance. A ruby engagement ring is sure to turn heads, whether it is fashioned in a traditional solitaire style or encircled by brilliant diamonds. If you are interested in this gemstone, try July ruby diamonds to delve deeper.

Let’s now examine the appeal of blue sapphire engagement rings as we move into the following area.

Blue Sapphire

Let’s examine the remarkable appeal of blue sapphire engagement rings as a stylish substitute for conventional diamond bands. Deep navy to vivid cornflower blue are just a few of the exquisite hues available in blue sapphires.

Blue sapphire engagement rings are a fantastic option for the following three reasons:

  • Color Variations: Because blue sapphires are available in a variety of tones, you can choose the ideal shade to complement your particular taste and style. Blue sapphires come in a variety of hues, from delicate pastels to rich royal blue.
  • Alternative Engagement Band Options: A blue sapphire as the focal point of your band gives a distinctive spin on the conventional diamond ring. It distinguishes you from the throng and highlights your uniqueness.
  • Pop of Color: Adding a blue sapphire to your engagement ring gives it a vivid pop of color that is stylish and striking. Your ring becomes genuinely unique as it adds a unique touch of flair and personality.

With their gorgeous colors and capacity to produce a dramatic splash of color on your finger, blue sapphire engagement rings present an alluring substitute for diamond rings.


We suggest investigating the beauty of February amethyst gemstones when thinking about substitutes for your diamond engagement ring. For those seeking a distinctive and cost-effective substitute for diamonds, amethyst is a breathtaking purple gemstone.

This colorful stone is well-known for its deep hue and mystical qualities, which makes it a significant option for an engagement ring. Not only is amethyst less expensive than diamonds, but its unique color makes it stand out. Its reasonable price enables you to select a larger stone or take into account other elements, including accent stones or a distinctive band design.

Amethyst is a great alternative to think about if you’re searching for a non-traditional option that nonetheless radiates beauty.


As a gorgeous substitute for your diamond engagement ring, we strongly advise you to think about emeralds. Emeralds have a striking green color and timeless appeal that may really stand out.

Here are three excellent reasons to choose emerald:

  • Genuine Emeralds: Choosing a genuine emerald adds distinction and authenticity to your ring. Emeralds are a unique choice for couples looking for something really special because each one has its own unique hue and properties.
  • Diamond Alternatives: Emerald engagement rings are a stunning substitute for customary diamond engagement rings. Their vivid green hue makes for a gorgeous and eye-catching piece of jewelry that elevates any environment with a hint of sophistication and elegance.
  • Color Grade and Hardness: Consider the color grade and hardness of the emerald before choosing one. Seek emeralds that have exceptional transparency and a stunning green hue. Furthermore, emeralds are appropriate for daily use because of their Mohs hardness value of roughly 7.5.

Embrace the beauty and allure of emerald and think about using it in place of your diamond engagement ring.


Opal is a stunning option for an engagement ring that is a genuinely one-of-a-kind and colorful substitute for diamonds. Opals can have flaming reds and oranges or calming blues and greens, and their captivating color play is well recognized. For individuals seeking a unique engagement ring that makes a statement and injects some color into their jewelry collection, this diamond is ideal.

Additionally, opals are the birthstone for October, which makes them an especially meaningful option for anybody born in that month. There are a variety of settings and styles available for opal engagement rings, so you may pick the ideal piece that complements your style and demeanor. An opal engagement ring is guaranteed to create a statement and turn into a treasured memento of your love, whether it is set in a halo setting with accent diamonds or is set in a solitaire.

Fluorescent Diamonds

For your diamond engagement ring, fluorescent diamonds are an intriguing and distinctive option. When exposed to UV light, these diamonds have a unique quality that makes them flash brightly.

Fluorescent diamonds are an excellent option for anyone looking for a non-traditional engagement ring for the following three reasons:

Ethereal Beauty: Your ring gains a captivating touch from the brilliant sparkle of these diamonds. Envision a delicate, ethereal glow paired with the brilliance and shine of a diamond.

Individuality: Selecting a vivid diamond makes your engagement ring stand out from the others. It stands out and gives your jewelry collection a unique touch because of its vivid light.

Cost-effective: Compared to their non-fluorescent cousins, fluorescent diamonds are frequently less expensive. This enables you to get a more substantial, larger stone without going over budget.

For those who are navigating the myriad options and seeking the best place to buy an engagement ring, it’s worth considering the allure of fluorescent diamonds. As a gorgeous and affordable substitute for conventional diamond engagement rings, think about luminous diamonds. They’re a great option for people looking for something really exceptional because of their distinct glow and reasonable price.

Salt and Pepper Diamonds

For your diamond engagement ring, though, you might want to think about salt and pepper diamonds if you’re searching for a really one-of-a-kind and unusual choice.

One kind of diamond substitute that has grown in popularity recently is the salt and pepper diamond. These diamonds are distinguished by their exquisite and distinctive inclusion patterns, which give them a peppered and salt-like appearance.

Salt and pepper diamonds are ideal for individuals looking for a non-traditional engagement ring since they have a more organic and natural appearance than typical diamonds.

Because they are frequently acquired from small-scale mines and are not as prone to environmental and social concerns as regular diamond mining, these diamonds are also a wonderful option for individuals who value ethical sourcing.

A genuinely unique choice for alternative engagement rings is provided by salt and pepper diamonds.

Engagement Jewelry as Alternatives

There are other kinds of engagement jewelry to take into consideration while looking for alternatives to traditional engagement rings. Watches, bracelets, necklaces, eternity bands, and even men’s engagement rings are among them.

Couples can show their uniqueness and sense of style with any of these options, which provide a stylish and distinctive substitute for the conventional diamond engagement ring.

Engagement jewelry offers a variety of possibilities for individuals who want something distinctive, regardless of whether you choose a statement piece or a more understated accent.


One alternative to an engagement ring could be to include a watch in our jewelry selections. A watch can be more than just a useful timepiece; it can also be an eye-catching piece of fashion. These are three options to think about:

Diamond Alternative: Choose a watch with a cubic zirconia stone in lieu of a conventional diamond. In terms of brilliance and sparkle, these stones are quite similar to diamonds, although they are less expensive.

White Sapphire: Opt for a watch that features a central white sapphire. Though they look similar to diamonds, white sapphires have a unique and elegant touch.

Choose a watch with black diamonds for a daring and unique style. A bold and captivating piece of jewelry is created by the contrast between the black diamonds and the watch’s design.

You may be creative and unique while yet keeping an air of refinement and elegance when you choose your engagement ring by including a timepiece.

Eternity Band

We think it’s a great idea to replace traditional engagement rings with an eternity band. The classic engagement ring with a stone in the center can be beautifully replaced with eternity rings. Usually, these bands have an endless row of gemstones—diamonds or other expensive stones—encircling the whole thing. Their eternal love and devotion symbolism make them an ideal option for an engagement ring.

To create a distinctive and customized design, eternity bands can be worn alone or stacked with other wedding bands. They can be fashioned with a variety of metals and jewels, making them a flexible and reasonably priced alternative to diamond jewelry. For individuals seeking a distinctive engagement ring, an eternity band is a gorgeous option, whether you’d rather have a standard diamond eternity band or a colorful gemstone alternative.


Necklaces make meaningful and distinctive alternatives to engagement rings, even though they might not be the most conventional choice.

Envision donning a delicate gold necklace that is studded with a brilliant gemstone pendant as a representation of your love and dedication.

Imagine a delicate, nostalgic necklace with elaborate decorations that would lend a touch of beauty to your bridal ensemble.

Imagine owning a personalized and sentimental piece of jewelry in the form of a charm necklace, where each charm would symbolize a unique occasion or experience you shared with your significant other.

You can still express your unique personality and sense of style while keeping the core of your love story intact by choosing a necklace instead of an engagement ring.

This non-traditional option can be a stunning and personal symbol of your dedication, whether it’s a gemstone necklace or a diamond substitute.


Bracelets are our number one pick for an alternative to engagement rings since they provide a classy and adaptable way to express your dedication.

A bracelet can be an exquisite substitute for a diamond, showcasing priceless stones in a distinctive and fashionable manner. There are countless possibilities to fit your own style, whether you go for a dramatic cuff or a delicate tennis bracelet.

Consider moissanite, sapphires, or even colored gemstones like rubies or emeralds as alternatives to diamonds. Depending on your taste, these gemstones can be set in either white or yellow gold.

A bracelet not only gives your outfit a glamorous touch, but it also acts as a continual reminder of your love and commitment.

Men’s Engagement Ring

In what ways can men incorporate jewelry into the engagement ritual as an alternative to traditional engagement rings? Here are three options to consider:

Men’s Engagement Rings: Men might choose to show off their love and dedication by choosing their own engagement rings. To produce a customized and manly appeal, these rings can be fashioned using distinctive styles and materials like wood, tungsten, or titanium.

Choose an Alternative Gemstone: Men can select gemstones other than diamonds for their engagement rings. The ring can be made more sophisticated and unique by using stones like black diamonds, emeralds, or sapphires.

Unique Designs: Men can work with jewelers to design unique engagement ring sets that express their interests and personalities. The options for making a unique item are numerous, ranging from complex engravings to striking, contemporary designs.

Men who look into these options might select engagement rings that are distinctive, reasonably priced, and accurately symbolize their love and dedication.

Let us now explore the process of selecting the ideal alternative to a diamond engagement ring.

How to Choose a Diamond Engagement Ring Alternative

We should concentrate on the distinctive qualities and meanings of various gemstones when thinking of alternatives to diamond engagement rings. Couples can choose a ring that expresses their unique preferences and style thanks to the availability of diamond substitutes. When making this crucial choice, keep in mind a few well-liked diamond substitutes.

The sapphire engagement ring is a common option for couples. There are many different colors of sapphires; the most popular color is blue. Because of their reputation for toughness and their 9 Mohs rating, they are appropriate for daily use. As a symbol of honesty, sincerity, and loyalty, sapphires are ideal for a sentimental engagement ring.

The emerald engagement ring is an additional choice to think over. On the Mohs hardness scale, emeralds are ranked 7.5-8 and are prized for their vivid green color. They have a timeless appeal and can be made into a personalized ring by choosing from a variety of shapes. The engagement ring has additional significance because emeralds represent fertility, love, and rebirth.

engagement ring alternatives

Because of its delicate pink hue, morganite is a stylish substitute for diamonds. Its hardness grade of 7.5-8 makes it appropriate for daily wear, and it resembles pink diamonds quite a bit. Because they are members of the same family, aquamarine and montanite both need comparable upkeep and attention. It is a significant option for an engagement ring because it represents healing, love, and compassion.

The durability, hardness, and symbolic significance of the gemstone should all be taken into account when selecting a substitute for a diamond. Couples can choose the ideal diamond substitute that perfectly suits their taste and love tale because each gemstone has special qualities and appeal of its own. Finding the ideal diamond substitute for your engagement ring can also be facilitated by speaking with a jeweler.

Diamond Engagement Ring Alternatives

Weighing the benefits and drawbacks is crucial when thinking about alternatives to diamond engagement rings.

Alternatives to diamonds provide more affordability, bigger stone counts, and a distinctive, customized appearance. They need more care, though, and could not be as strong as diamonds.

When choosing a gemstone, it’s important to take into account aspects like your lifestyle, your preferred hue, and the gemstone’s strength.


What benefits might alternative diamond engagement rings offer?

Consider the following benefits when selecting a non-diamond choice for your engagement ring:

Cost: Compared to actual diamonds, diamond substitutes are typically less expensive, enabling you to get a larger stone for less money. If you need to take your budget into account, this might be really helpful.

Uniqueness: Choosing a diamond substitute rather than a typical one makes your ring stand out and gives it a personal touch. Colored gemstones may be a daring and fashionable option, adding a splash of color to pieces like rubies, sapphires, and emeralds.

Versatility: Diamond substitutes are adaptable in terms of appearance and style. You can select a ring that precisely suits your tastes and style thanks to the variety of gemstones and cuts available.


The drawbacks of alternatives to diamond engagement rings should be acknowledged. Although these substitutes present a more cost-effective choice for pairs, their durability might not match that of diamonds. Wearability and durability are influenced by the unique chemical and physical characteristics of each gemstone. Pearls and opals, for instance, are softer stones that need more maintenance and might not be appropriate for daily wear.

Non-traditional alternatives might not be appealing to everyone, and some people might prefer the traditional look of a diamond. Every gemstone has different maintenance and care needs, therefore, it’s crucial to keep that in mind because some may need more care than others.

Notwithstanding these drawbacks, alternatives to diamond engagement rings come in a range of hues and let you select a special and exquisite gemstone.

The last word on alternatives to diamond engagement rings will be given in the following section.

Final Word

In conclusion, exploring non-diamond engagement ring selections can lead you to the perfect symbol of your love, aligning with both your personal flair and budget. Whether you’re captivated by the vibrant allure of rubies, sapphires, and emeralds, the contemporary brilliance of lab-created diamonds, or the historical charm of heirloom rings, there’s a treasure that perfectly matches your unique love story.  Remember to balance your choice with your lifestyle, aesthetic, and budget for a decision that you’ll cherish forever. For a curated collection of exquisite alternatives, consider browsing through Blue Nile or James Allen to find that dream ring.


BrighterGuide is dedicated to providing accurate and relevant information as you explore the wonderful world of diamonds and jewelry. To this end, our writers refer to primary information sources in building each article that appears on this website. These include, but are not limited to, published news articles, government portals, research papers, and more.

  1. Gemological Institute of America. (n.d.). Gemological Institute Of America | All About Gemstones – GIA. https://www.gia.edu/
  2. American Gem Trade Association. (2019, December 10). Gemstones: The American Gem Trade Association. AGTA. https://agta.org/education/gemstones/

Leave a Comment